Could This Be the End of Affirmative Action at Holy Cross?

September 24th, 2012 by 
HC Video Player 2.11

 

In October 2012, the Supreme Court of the United States will hear arguments on Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, a case that challenges the constitutionality of race-based affirmative action in admissions programs at public colleges and universities. Many at the College of the Holy Cross, and other public and private institutions around the country, are watching this case closely for the possible repercussions it could have on the future of affirmative action plans at all higher education institutions. If the ruling opinion is to end affirmative action at public institutions, it could quickly ripple to encompass any private institution, such as Holy Cross, that accepts federal funds.

Holy Cross has a celebrated history of recruiting a diverse student body, and the College filed an amicus brief in the case with seven other Catholic colleges and universities. The brief argues that the Supreme Court has long upheld academic freedom, and the institutions’ admissions policies should be protected by the First Amendment.

The College, its students, and its alumni have a stake in this. One way or another, the end of affirmative action would change life on campus. So this fall, the College’s Rev. Michael C. McFarland, S.J. Center for Religion, Ethics and Culture, tasked with probing these difficult, ethical issues in public forums, is taking on the topic of affirmative action and its value at Holy Cross.

Add your voice to the discussion.

On Sept. 17, Harvard Law Professor Randall Kennedy gave a public lecture here on “The Supreme Court and Affirmative Action.” In his talk, he highlighted key decisions in race-based affirmative action in higher education over the last 34 years. He offered a prediction of Supreme Court’s ruling in Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin. And he laid out his own case defending race-based affirmative action as a form of restorative justice to historically disadvantaged populations.

Watch Prof. Kennedy’s lecture online here.

With that background, the McFarland Center now poses the question to its constituents, students, alumni, faculty, and staff: Does affirmative action help or hinder us in becoming a more just society?

A “fishbowl” discussion will take place on Monday, Oct. 1 at 4:30 p.m. in the Rehm Library. During the fishbowl, a small group of faculty, students and alumni seated in an inner circle will discuss the topic, before opening up the floor for questions and comments by the audience seated in an outer circle. Featured participants will include Margaret Freije, associate dean of the College; Kendy Hess, Brake-Smith Assistant Professor in Social Philosophy and Ethics; Darrell Byers ’83, director of development at WBUR; and students Patricia Giglio ’14, Ariel Jimenez ’13, Christopher Theobalt ’13 and Antonio Willis-Berry ’13.

All are welcome to attend the fishbowl. The event also will be recorded and available for online viewing in the days leading up to and following the Supreme Court proceedings. Submit your comments online to help us continue a meaningful dialogue on the future of affirmative action at Holy Cross.

Related Information:

| More
Tags
Categories
News, Videos

 

Comments (1)
  1. Andrew says:

    This is certainly an interesting topic and one that I’m glad to see the greater HC community taking an interest in, especially considering Justice Thomas’ role in the Court.

    My personal view is that race-based affirmative action, while certainly strengthening diversity, creates an inherently unequal admissions process for all involved. Applicants are left to wonder whether they were admitted or rejected not based on academic merit or ability, but rather the color of their skin – a factor over which they have no control.

    If true equality is the fundamental basis for civil rights, how can one justify such an unequal process in which one’s race, gender, or any other non-merit factor impacts an admissions decision? Would it not be more equal to all involved if applicants were selected solely on their academic merit and strength of character, rather than their race?

    Undoubtedly the College will address this interesting issue with the rigor it deserves. Looking forward to the healthy dialogue and reading about the Supreme Court’s decision.

02/16/17 Holy Cross Faculty Member Recognized for Contributions to Catholic Higher Education
02/16/17 Religious Studies Professor Offers Response to the Potential Repeal of the Johnson Amendment
02/15/17 Holy Cross Names Dan Kim Vice President for Communications
02/15/17 Margaret Peterlin ’93 Joins State Department as Secretary Rex Tillerson’s Chief of Staff
See All
See All
Featured Videos

See video
Holy Cross Faculty Member Recognized for Contributions to Catholic Higher Education

Watch Video >
See video
Time-Lapse Video: 13 Inches of Snow Blanket Campus

Watch Video >
See video
Video: Former U.S. Poet Laureate Billy Collins ’63 Honored as Helmerich Distinguished Author, Reads Poetry on NPR

Watch Video >
See video
Video, Photo Gallery: Holy Cross Wishes You a Merry Christmas

Watch Video >
See video
Video: Holy Cross History Professor Featured in PBS Pearl Harbor Documentary

Watch Video >
See video
Video: Two-Time Heisman Candidate Gordie Lockbaum ’88 Featured by ESPN in ‘30 for 30 Short’

Watch Video >
See video
Video: Holy Cross Students are ‘More Engaged’

Watch Video >
See video
Video: Take a Look at Campus Life After the Sun Sets

Watch Video >
See video
Photo Gallery, Video: Class of 2020 Receives A Holy Cross Welcome on Move-In Day

Watch Video >
See video
VIDEO: Stephen Colbert Talks Holy Cross in Web Exclusive

Watch Video >
More

Summer OL Training
6/14/2017

See More >


Summer OL Training
6/13/2017

See More >


Summer OL Training
6/12/2017

See More >


SAM'S CLUB
6/8/2017

See More >


Summer OL Training
6/8/2017

See More >


Sexual Misconduct Policy Training
6/7/2017
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 519
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 519: Open to Campus Community OnlySee More >


Women's Forum Weekly Meeting
5/11/2017

See More >


MSO Advocate Program (Event canceled)
5/11/2017

See More >


AAC Luncheon
5/10/2017

See More >


Athletics
5/10/2017

See More >


Kimball Captains' Senior Send Off Dinner
5/9/2017

See More >


Women's Track and Field Banquet
5/9/2017

See More >


Dean's Spring Address
5/9/2017

See More >


Dean's Address
5/9/2017

See More >


Summer Internship Send Off Meeting
5/9/2017

See More >


Summer Internship Send Off Meeting
5/8/2017

See More >


Cinco de Mayo
5/5/2017

See More >


Women's Forum Weekly Meeting
5/4/2017

See More >


Real Estate Club Meeting
5/4/2017
Edith Stein Hall 118C
Edith Stein Hall 118C: The main goal of the Real Estate Club will be to expose HC students to a broad... See More >

More Holy Cross in the News

02/15/17

Margaret Peterlin ’93 Joins State Department as Secretary Rex Tillerson’s Chief of Staff

The Washington Post

Maintaining a cohesive team at the State Department is critical to the agency’s future success, writes Josh Rogin, a columnist for the Global Opinions section of The...

02/14/17

Religious Studies Professor Reflects on Shaker Culture, Insights

The Conversation

Moved by the recent passing of Sister Frances Carr, thought to be one of the last known Shaker, professor of religious studies Joanne M. Pierce discusses Shaker legacy and...

02/14/17

Why Early Aid Letters Matter: Holy Cross Financial Aid Expert Comments on New FAFSA Rules

U.S. News & World Report

Lynne Myers, director of financial aid at College of the Holy Cross, explains why the changes to the financial aid process, effective for the 2017-2018 academic year, could...