Transcending Partisan Lines: Students Discuss Gun Control, Rights in Multiple On-Campus Events

Through a fishbowl discussion and an open conversation with a professor of philosophy, students explored nuances of intractable social problems
April 24th, 2018 by 

Students, faculty and staff discuss the topic of guns in a moderated fishbowl.
Students, faculty and staff discuss the topic of guns in a moderated fishbowl. Photo by Austin Bosworth '18

“If I’m not speaking to you as an expert on guns, then I’m speaking to you as a human being,” Joseph Lawrence, professor of philosophy, said to a room full of students at the start of a conversation about the weighty, but timely, topic. “And if I speak to you as a human being, I would hope that would make it easier for you to respond to what I have to say as the human beings that you are.”

Lawrence was speaking at “Guns: Transcending the Partisan Divide,” one of two events sponsored by the Office of Diversity and Inclusion and the Student Government Association aimed at addressing the issue of guns, gun violence and gun control in a respectful and understanding way.

In an effort to humanize the issue and catalyze dialogue, Lawrence shared his own narrative of growing up deep within gun culture in the hills of Kentucky. “I got my first BB gun when I was five or six, graduated to a .22 rifle when I was 12, got a 410 shotgun by the time I was 14 and by the time I was 16, that went up to a 20-gauge shotgun — I shot guns a lot.”

One of 15 children, Lawrence was especially close to his older brother, Allen, who died by gun suicide shortly after graduating high school.

“That,” he shares, “was my introduction to philosophy. That was my introduction to the idea that you actually have to think about things seriously. That was my introduction to the idea that the world of thought is not some kind of parlor game in which people banter about their opposing ideological positions.”

Based on his experiences with guns, Lawrence told students he truly believes the gun issue is one that can transcend the partisan divide.

“If you’re a good democrat, you’re going to be convinced that in order to feel safe in the world, the world has to do a better job of regulating guns. If you’re a republican, you’re going to feel equally strongly that if you want to feel safe in this world, you should have a gun so you can protect yourself against the bad guys. Both sides frame the issue solely in terms of safety. Both sides frame the issue in terms of fear.”

After some opening remarks, Lawrence engaged the student in active dialogues. One student asked: “When we, in the name of fear, want to prevent dangers that we might encounter, do you think we as human beings go too far, to the point where we become ridiculous in trying to protect our lives?”

“The consensus on both sides of the political debate is, ‘We just have to find the best way to stay safe,'” Lawrence replied. “From a philosophical position, you can’t make the world perfectly secure. Staying alive cannot possibly be the goal of a fully human life given that each of us will die in the end. The real problem with guns is not that they do a poor job of protecting us, but that they empower us in a way that contributes to our moral corruption, making us see enemies even where there are none, making us willing at any moment to destroy another human being.”

In addition to this conversation, roughly 100 students, faculty and staff also attended a fishbowl on guns that used interactive live polling to gauge personal opinions on gun-related issues.

Amit Taneja, dean for diversity, equity and inclusion, who moderated the fishbowl, said it was helpful to establish from the get-go that the vast majority of participants were interested in reducing gun-based violence.

“A shared common goal can help us understand that those with different approaches and ideas are not our enemies, but that we all wanted similar outcomes. The common goals prevent us from dismissing others without hearing them first.”

“While the discussion did get tense for a short period over the perception of certain guns — namely the AR-15 — it remained a respectful atmosphere that valued open communication rather than debate,” said Austin Bosworth ’18, a political science major. “The biggest takeaway for me was the need for greater research on gun violence, and the way in which students recognized the connections between mental health, other forms of violence and gun deaths. It’s important to have these discussions because it breaks down the ‘us vs. them’ mentality by humanizing the other side of the debate.”

Taneja notes that he never imagined students would leave either conversation with a consensus on how to solve the issue of gun violence. Instead, he sees both events as an opportunity for deeper discernment, a foundational principle of Jesuit higher education.

“My hope is that students learn the tools necessary to engage in dialogue and reflection with others that they deeply disagree with. If we could solve the pressing problems of the world by yelling matches and debates alone, we would have world peace by now.”

| More

Comments are closed.

12/11/18 Holy Cross’ Long-Term Study Abroad Programs Recognized for Tenth Year in a Row
12/04/18 Holy Cross Religious Studies Professor Is Sought-After Expert on New Religious Movements
11/30/18 Holy Cross Earns High Marks for Dining Services
11/30/18 Holy Cross Classics Professor Discusses Evolving Military Rations With HISTORY
See All

Multi-faith Community Prayer Day
1/21/2019
Featured
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 2
Multi-Faith Prayer Service, Tuesday, January 22, 2019 at...
See More >>


MPE Meeting
1/28/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 406(08)
Open to the Public
See More >>


MLK Book Read: Session 1
1/28/2019
Office of Diversity and Inclusion
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Suite A - 4th Fl
We are excited to announce the fourth annual MLK Winter...
See More >>


Crusader Internship Fund Orientation Session
1/28/2019
Center for Career Development
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 409
Come to the Crusader Internship Fund Orientation to learn all the details...
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
1/28/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
1/29/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


MLK Book Read: Session 2
1/29/2019
Office of Diversity and Inclusion
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Suite A - 4th Fl
We are excited to announce the fourth annual MLK Winter...
See More >>


MLK Book Read: Session 3
1/30/2019
Office of Diversity and Inclusion
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Suite A - 4th Fl
We are excited to announce the fourth annual MLK Winter...
See More >>


Crusader Internship Fund Wait List Info Session
1/30/2019
Center for Career Development
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 401
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
1/30/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


Little Women
1/31/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Little Women Book by Allan Knee, based on the novel by Louisa May AlcottMusic...
See More >>


Lecture: Speaker - Jill Lepore
1/31/2019
McFarland Center for Religion
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Ballroom & 328
Jill Lepore is the David Woods Kemper ’41...
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
1/31/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


Little Women
2/1/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Little Women Book by Allan Knee, based on the novel by Louisa May AlcottMusic...
See More >>


Little Women
2/2/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Little Women Book by Allan Knee, based on the novel by Louisa May AlcottMusic...
See More >>


Little Women
2/3/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the novel by Louisa May AlcottMusic...
See More >>


Careers in Psychology & Behavioral Health Info Session hosted by William James College
2/4/2019
Center for Career Development
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 304(05)
Stop by the William James College info table to learn more about...
See More >>


William James College Info Table
2/4/2019
Center for Career Development
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 3
Stop by the William James College info table to learn more...
See More >>


MLK Book Read: Session 4
2/4/2019
Office of Diversity and Inclusion
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Suite A - 4th Fl
We are excited to announce the fourth annual MLK Winter...
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
2/4/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
2/5/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


Crusader Internship Fund Orientation Session
2/5/2019
Center for Career Development
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 403
Come to the Crusader Internship Fund Orientation to learn all the details...
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
2/6/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


Little Women
2/7/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Little Women Book by Allan Knee, based on the novel by Louisa May AlcottMusic...
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
2/7/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


Little Women
2/8/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Little Women Book by Allan Knee, based on the novel by Louisa May AlcottMusic...
See More >>


Ticket Sales - Little Women: The Musical
2/8/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the...
See More >>


Little Women
2/9/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Little Women Book by Allan Knee, based on the novel by Louisa May AlcottMusic...
See More >>


Little Women
2/10/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Little WomenBook by Allan Knee, based on the novel by Louisa May AlcottMusic...
See More >>


MPE Meeting
2/11/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 406(08)
Open to the Public
See More >>


Faculty Conversation Series-175th Anniversary
2/13/2019
175th Anniversary
Dinand Library Faculty Room
Subject: Mentoring: Spiritual Director as Model/MetaphorFaculty Conversation...
See More >>


Mimecast Info Table
2/19/2019
Center for Career Development Open to Campus Community Only Categories: Center for Career Development
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 5
Stop by the Mimecast Info Table speak to representatives...
See More >>


MPE Meeting
2/25/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 402(03)
Open to the Public
See More >>


Lecture: Samuel Moyn on the Christian Invention of Human Dignity
2/26/2019
McFarland Center for Religion
Carol and Park B. Smith Hall Rehm Lib
Samuel Moyn, professor of law and history at Yale University,...
See More >>


MPE Meeting
3/11/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Suite B/C - 4th Fl
Open to the Public
See More >>


MPE Meeting
3/11/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 304(05)
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


The Living Museum Exhibit
3/12/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Suite B/C - 4th Fl
Open to the Public
See More >>


Faculty Conversation Series-175th Anniversary
3/14/2019
175th Anniversary
Dinand Library Faculty Room
Subject: EloquenceFaculty Conversation Series on Ignatian Pedagogy. The...
See More >>


Holy Cross College Choir Concert
3/15/2019
Music
St Joseph Memorial Chapel St Joseph Chapel
The Holy Cross Choirs are back from their tour down the East...
See More >>


Organ concert - Benjamin Alard
3/17/2019
Music
St Joseph Memorial Chapel St Joseph Chapel
Benjamin Alard, OrganistChurch: Saint-Louis-en-Île,...
See More >>


MPE Meeting
3/25/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Suite B/C - 4th Fl
Open to the Public
See More >>


MPE Meeting
3/25/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 304(05)
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


175th Jesuits and Music Concert
3/29/2019
Music
St Joseph Memorial Chapel St Joseph Chapel
Many Holy Cross musical ensembles and performers will join...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/1/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


53rd Annual Hanify-Howland Lecture
4/2/2019
Hanify-Howland Memorial Lecture
Holy Cross Campus
The 53rd annual Hanify-Howland Memorial Lecture will be held April 2, 2019 in the...
See More >>


Science Engineering & Technology Networking Night
4/2/2019
Mathematics and Computer Science
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 406
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/2/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/3/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/4/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Once in a Lifetime By George S. Kaufman and Moss HartApril 4-6 &...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/4/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/5/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Once in a Lifetime By George S. Kaufman and Moss HartApril 4-6 &...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/5/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 1
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/6/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Once in a Lifetime By George S. Kaufman and Moss HartApril 4-6 &...
See More >>


COPE Well Week
4/8/2019
Counseling Center
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 402(03)
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


MPE Meeting
4/8/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 304(05)
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


MPE Meeting
4/8/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Suite B/C - 4th Fl
Open to the Public
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/8/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 2
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


COPE Well Week
4/9/2019
Counseling Center
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 402(03)
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/9/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 2
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


COPE Well Week
4/10/2019
Counseling Center
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 401
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/10/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 2
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/11/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Once in a Lifetime By George S. Kaufman and Moss HartApril 4-6 &...
See More >>


COPE Well Week
4/11/2019
Counseling Center
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 304(05)
Open to Campus Community Only
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/11/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 2
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/12/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Once in a Lifetime By George S. Kaufman and Moss HartApril 4-6 &...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/12/2019
Theatre
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center Lobby Table 2
LOBBY TABLE - Once in a LifetimeBy George S. Kaufman and...
See More >>


Once in a Lifetime
4/13/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Once in a Lifetime By George S. Kaufman and Moss HartApril 4-6 &...
See More >>


Academic Conference
4/24/2019
Office of the Vice President for Academic Affairs
Haberlin Hall 219
Open to the Public
See More >>


Academic Conference
4/24/2019
Office of the Vice President for Academic Affairs
Smith Laboratories 155
Open to the Public
See More >>


Academic Conference
4/24/2019
Office of the Vice President for Academic Affairs
Smith Laboratories 154
Open to the Public
See More >>


Academic Conference
4/24/2019
Office of the Vice President for Academic Affairs
O'Neil Hall 112
Open to the Public
See More >>


Holy Cross College Choir Concert
4/27/2019
Music
St Joseph Memorial Chapel St Joseph Chapel
Giacomo Carissimi was the first great composer of oratorios,...
See More >>


Chapel Artist Series Organ Concert - Pavel Kohout
4/28/2019
Music
St Joseph Memorial Chapel St Joseph Chapel
Pavel Kohout, OrganistInternational Concert Organist, Prague,...
See More >>


MPE Meeting
4/29/2019
Office of Multicultural Education
Henry M. Hogan Campus Center 406(09)
Open to the Public
See More >>


Dance Concert
5/1/2019
Theatre
O'Kane Hall Fenwick Theatre
Dance ConcertMay 1 at 7:00 PM and 9:00 PMFenwick Theatre – 2nd...
See More >>


175th Anniversary Scavenger Hunt
5/17/2019
Featured Employee
Outdoor starting at Hogan
This Scavenger Hunt is being put on by the Mission and Identity Subcommittee...
See More >>

See All